AudioBook Review: Montana Promises by Velda Brotherton

My first introduction to a western historical romance, and Velda Brotherton managed to provide a story that was rich in character, scenery and pathos before bringing us that happy ending.

Tressie has just lived through the abandonment of her father and the death of her mother when she discovers a wounded and unconscious man on her property.  She pulls on her “must do” panties, and takes responsibility for nursing this unknown man.

Reed is a confederate soldier on the run after stealing a union horse.  His plans are to head west, and Tressie convinces him to take her to track her father in the gold fields.   Reed is understandably reluctant, but agrees to accompany and protect Tressie: after all she has managed admirably so far.

Unfortunately, Tressie seems to have some sort of reversion in her personality: from strong and determined, fairly independent and matter of fact, she becomes petulant and princess, a wilting flower and far more the stereotypical female of the time.  While Reed does still take care, and it’s obvious he cares for her, there are so many obstacles to overcome before their lives can begin to take form.

Jeff Justus is the narrator for the story, and the best option I have for describing his style is to have you imagine the voice you would choose for a western narration, improve it 10% and you approach his style.  A solid and clear enunciation with a clear accent, he doesn’t make great efforts to emulate a woman’s voice, merely drops his tone and softens the vowels: while his subtle change of delivery when portraying Reed’s voice is evident but not distracting.  A thoroughly pleasant listen, the tension and hesitation when approaching the more dangerous or rough situations is evidenced in his delivery giving weight to the description provided by the words.

I will admit to not being particularly fond of Tressie after the first third of the book, but I did see the characters emotional connection and growing relationship even as I wondered if the addition of the sex scenes was more contemporary than I would expect in a historical romance.   For my first historical romance of this sub-genre, it was a book that held my interest and kept me entertained.

Stars:  Overall: 4  Narration 5  Story 3

AudioBook Review: Montana Promises by Velda Brotherton

Title: Montana Promises
Author: Velda Brotherton
Genre: Historical Romance
Narrator: Jeff Justus
Published by: Self-Produced, Self-Published
Source: Audio Producer
Pages: 281
Audio Length: 10 Hours: 59 minutes
Rated: four-stars
Get Your Copy: Amazon AllRomance
See this Title on Goodreads

At 17, Tressie Majors is stranded in a soddie on the high plains when her mother dies in childbirth. Reed Bannon flees a Yankee soldier after stealing his horse. He was shot and is almost dead when he arrives at the soddie while Tressie is burying her mother.

Tressie desires only one thing. To pursue her father who abandoned the family to go in search of gold at Alder Gulch near Virginia City. She nurses Reed back to health in the hope that he will take her west, but he leaves without her because he fears for her life if she goes with him.

She follows and the two have an adventurous trek to Virginia City and on through the gold fields in search of her father. Tressie must get over her hate and need for revenge and Reed must solve his problem of being wanted by the law and the army before the two of them can have a life together.

A copy of this title was provided via Audio Producer for purpose of honest review. I was not compensated for this review: all conclusions are my own responsibility.

About Velda Brotherton

Velda Brotherton writes of romance in the old west with an authenticity that
makes her many historical characters ring true. A knowledge of the rich history of
our country comes through in both her fiction and nonfiction books, as well as in
her writing workshops and speaking engagements. She just as easily steps out of
the past into contemporary settings to create novels about women with the ability
to conquer life’s difficult challenges. Tough heroines, strong and gentle heroes,
villains to die for, all live in the pages of her novels and books.


Get 1 free audiobook credit at!